Does Strategy Need Innovating? A primer on Lean Strategy for Startups

Does Strategy Need Innovating? A primer on Lean Strategy for StartupsSeveral months ago I set up my own business to work with startups, forward thinking small businesses and social enterprises seeking to scale and grow. I wanted to bring the useful elements of my ten years experience as a corporate management consultant to new ventures.

I hold a strong view that there is a lot that the corporate world can learn from startups, but that there is also a lot that startups can learn from the corporate world, particularly when it comes to scaling. These two worlds are constructively colliding at the moment and I’m fascinated to see where it is going to take us.

A few observations on strategy in the startup world

With a background in strategy consulting, my attention quickly turned to how startups approach business strategy. It didn’t take me long to realise that this topic is not really discussed. Since the dawn of management thinking, thought leaders have justified their existence through its study and eminent businesses have existed to help clients formulate and execute it. Yet in the startup world strategy is given very little attention. I decided to undertake a bit of research. My methodology was admittedly crude, but strategy is all about hypothesising!

Googling ‘strategy for startups’ returned a page of results dominated by articles on sales strategy, branding, marketing and advertising strategy, content strategy, IT strategy and exit strategy. All are important elements of an overarching business strategy but none of them will alone lead to business success.

With further searching, only two articles really stood out on the subject of business strategy for startups. The first is a blog post by the VC Fred Wilson. Encouraging all startups to make sure that they have a strategy, he provides intellectual definitions of what strategy really is and encourages readers to distinguish between strategy and tactics (a very common pitfall). The second post by Uzi Shmilovici, is more practically-focused. With a focus on disruption and the work of Clayton Christensen, he explains how startups should choose intelligent and specific tactics that support their overall strategy (another very common pitfall).

In the opening pages of The Lean Startup, Eric Ries sets the tone for lean startup success: a trifecta of vision, strategy and product. I was encouraged then that strategy is considered an important determinant. Turning to the book’s index though I found that only 2 pages are devoted to strategy as a concept. That’s not a criticism of The Lean Startup, the book provides a fantastic framework for legions of entrepreneurs across the globe and does not sell itself as a discourse on business strategy. But it’s interesting that little discussion is given to what strategy actually is. I use this example then only to set the tone for opening up further discussion, so that founders may be assisted further in their strategic thinking.

Don’t believe me? The importance of strategy for startups

Amusingly, Uzi Shmilovici probably answers my earlier about why strategy is not really discussed in the startup world. As he correctly points out “unfortunately, it suffers from a bad reputation among startups. It is associated with consultants who are paid millions of dollars only to come back with a two-by-two matrix of animals”. As far a perception goes, I concede that to be a fair point! Despite this, he is clear that “strategy is crucial for startup success. Startups usually operate in an environment of constrained resources while competing with strong incumbents. Hence, the right strategy can be a matter of life and death”.

And Fred Wilson succinctly states “don’t think you are going to win in business with a better product, more capital, or a bigger team…The winner in a market most often has the best strategy and executes it well”. I’m encouraged that such eminent VCs are pushing forward such points.

An Introduction to Lean Strategy for Startups

The business world is evolving at a rapid pace but the essence of good strategic thinking, a discipline which predates the birth of Jesus Christ, remains largely unchanged in my humble opinion. The ability of humans to take logical and structured approaches towards solving challenges of any kind would appear to be something that is rooted in our basic nature and behaviours.

The financial crisis, combined with more recent disruptive technologies, have led some to comment that ‘strategy is dead’. For me this is a huge over-exaggeration and an effort to sensationalise a debate. Strategy is not dead, we just need to reframe how we think about and approach it. In accordance with lean thinking, and the recent writings of individuals like Rita McGrath, what can be said to have changed is the pace at which strategy must be formulated and executed.

And that has some fascinating implications for startups. In my next post I go into more detail about how more traditional thinking on the subject of strategy might be aligned with modern startup approaches. Call it lean strategy for startups if you will. Principally I’ll explore:

  • The bit that most people get wrong… what strategy really is in the first place. It’s not to be confused with objectives and methodologies / frameworks;
  • The need, in any business, to consider strategy in a holistic and overarching way – a solid business strategy represents a strategic top layer that guides all aspects of your business, and it is not solely product focused; and
  • What is meant by lean strategy for startups. We’ll see that a critical component of strategy for startups and new ventures relates to the pace at which it must be formulated, executed and revised.

image credit: pixelmepink.com

BETA - Global Innovation Management Institute certification

Wait! Before you go…

Choose how you want the latest innovation content delivered to you:


What Does Innovation Mean for Smaller Business? Richard Hughes-Jones is an experienced management consultant, having spent most of his career with Deloitte UK and working in a senior management role for Her Majesty’s Treasury. He now works with high growth businesses, bringing strategic business thinking to support sustainable growth. Richard blogs about a range of business issues at FireLDN and is on Twitter @FireLDN

This entry was posted in Entrepreneurship, Innovation Perspectives, Leadership, Management, People & Skills, Strategy and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Does Strategy Need Innovating? A primer on Lean Strategy for Startups

  1. Pingback: Does Strategy Need Innovating? A primer on Lean...

  2. Pingback: Innovation Excellence | Does Strategy Need Inno...

  3. This is so so true. When mentoring and advising entrepreneurs, they balk when i talk about strategic planning until I explain it’s not a binder on a shelf but a living breathing guide for the business… an adaptive, actionable, testable living plan… the value is in both the questioning of assumptions and thinking that occurs in creating the strategy and in executing and adapting..

    • Thanks Deb, you are absolutely right. For me it is about getting across the point that strategy really doesn’t have to be that complicated… with a basic understanding what strategy (really) is, some evidence based assumptions and light touch but robust planning you really can give your business a competitive edge.

      Your point about the “thinking that occurs in creating the strategy” also resonates strongly. This links to the shortcomings of methodologies / frameworks which can be incredibly useful tools for identifying issues but they will not give you insightful answers. Brainpower alone is required for that!

  4. Karla Reyes says:

    As a business advisor, I find that my clients want to grow their businesses but often feel overwhelmed with what it all entails.

  5. Re-inviting the wheel is not needed by every start up out there and let’s face it there are more and more of them every day. That being said making the wheel better, now that’s something I think we all wished would happen every time we have to shell out the cash to put new tired on our gas guzzlers. To me innovation is what’s exciting all the start ups. I have been involved in a start up or two and know lean not only a good way to go but also a need one sometimes, but how can a start up hope to innovate without a strategy? Thanks for the post.

  6. Pingback: Does Strategy Need Innovating? A primer on Lean...

  7. Pingback: Strategy | The Roadmap Co.

  8. Teaching and consulting in both strategy and entrepreneurship, I realize more and more how important it is for the start-up entrepreneurs to have a strategic thinking. Successful entrepreneurs need to formulate well their long-term goals, to analyze the trends and to position well their business idea in the changing environment. Entrepreneurship is not just about “starting a business”, or “implementing a business model” – it is about sustainable positioning of an idea into the changing business, social and economic environment, considering how this idea might grow in the future.
    On another hand, big companies need to constantly innovate and be entrepreneurial – the “intrapreneurial” spirit and actions are very important for companies to survive nowadays, to be different, to look at innovative products and services in order to compete successfully.
    Thanks, Richard, for picking up this important topic!

  9. Pingback: Does strategy need innovating? A primer on Lean Strategy for startups

  10. Pingback: Strategy | The Roadmap Co.

  11. Gus Vlas says:

    pfff… How academic can we get? Compare Business, Start Ups to Sports.. Winning/Growing is a key element.
    Strategy is your upfront “Game Plan”, how you prepare on the relevant things ahead. Tactics is where you make the calls during execution, or adapt to changes. The better your preparation (strategy) the less surprises you will encounter while executing. Strategy supports your tactics here since you did prepare, or think about scenario’s.

    I have 25 years experience in Business Management, and currently I lecture students in Startegic Management – Common Framer Sense or Keep it Simple, Focussed and Relevant.

  12. Pingback: Innovation Excellence | Lean Strategy for Startups: it’s not sexy but it is important

  13. Pingback: Test | Startup Roadmap

  14. Pingback: Do tech start-ups understand strategic thinking? KPMG

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Keep Up to Date

  • FeedBurner
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Slideshare
  • Email
  • YouTube
  • IPhone
  • Amazon Kindle
  • Stumble Upon

Innovation Authors - Braden Kelley, Julie Anixter and Rowan Gibson

Your hosts, Braden Kelley, Julie Anixter and Rowan Gibson, are innovation writers, speakers and strategic advisors to many of the world’s leading companies.

“Our mission is to help you achieve innovation excellence inside your own organization by making innovation resources, answers, and best practices accessible for the greater good.”